The Empty Nest

Yesterday was Mother's Day. I have always been suspicious of this holiday as another Hallmark invention (a la Valentine's Day) exploiting vaguely religious roots to monetize the guilt of unexpressed love. My suspicions were confirmed: After animated birds delivered Mother's Day cards in a dozen different languages in an e-card I received yesterday, a link offered "a brief history of the holiday." It was indeed a Roman festival to honor the mother goddess Cybele, which was later appropriated by early Christians to honor the Virgin Mary.

What does it mean that the first link in my google search for "Cybele roman goddess"leads me to www.teenwitch.com where, among other options, I can stop corporate blood libel and take action for witches rights? From this site I can catch up on my pagan shopping and, after a few private lessons in casting spells, etc., earn my certificate as a High Priestess of Cybele. My teen witch activist friends also teach me that the Vatican is built on top of the original temple to Cybele, also known as Gaia -- the deified Mother Earth.

This last part interests me. I'm not the first woman in the History of the West to notice how the Christian Church removed the feminine creative powers from the Holy Equation. Maybe if I were raised Catholic I'd have a relationship with the Virgin Mary, but even Mary is a "mother of God" as opposed to being God(dess) herself. The Holy Family consists of a Father, a Son, and a Holy Ghost. Many mothers I know report feeling like ghosts much of the time.

As a mother to 3 boys under age 5, I'm aware that their experience with women is pretty focused on me. I'm not a Freudian, but it makes sense that their attachment to me is both intense and ambivalent. Truth be told, I experience ambivalence on the other side. I have loved (obviously) having these babies; I delight in their bodies and minds; I am wired to respond to their sleeping, eating, and emotional rhythms. I take pride in anticipating their needs, whether for cheese sticks and oranges on the walk home from school or for an early bedtime, and I consider it a reward to watch them run happily in the woods lost in a fantasy of jungle exploration. But I get annoyed by the constant migration of matter in my house (how did the toothpaste end up in the kitchen sink? Why are their socks under every chair and table in the living room?). I get irritated when, for example:
...My body becomes a jungle gym or "fire pole".
...My freshly made bed ends up in a heap of covers and pillows ("But Mom! It's our fort!").
...I give in to requests to make "green eggs" that no one will eat thanks to, of course, their gross color.
...I ask a thousand and one times to get shoes on while feet remain stubbornly bare.
...Within seconds of the older boys falling asleep, baby Tucker wakes up.
...Duncan and Reeve must both possess the same toy boat at exactly the same time, and therefore chase each other screaming with claws bared.
...My efforts to be Casual Mom, i.e. allow them to paint in the basement without supervision, result in (gee!) Reeve's body in paint from head to toe.
...My refusal to rent Scooby Doo and the Cyberchase from the movie store for the umpteenth time gives grounds for a sit-in protest, i.e. two screaming boys sitting on the sidewalk refusing to move.
...Jordy's and my rare efforts to go on a date elicit tragic laments about our neglectful parenting from Duncan.
...I wonder whether my time-out from "work" will be penalized by the sputtering end of my barely begun filmmaking career (or any career for that matter).
And I get positively furious when Duncan or Reeve hurt the baby, intentionally or unintentionally. (Mama Tiger rage instincts, it seems, bypass my Homo Sapiens' "Positive Discipline" techniques.)

But in the middle of the other night, a chilling vision appeared. I was nursing Tucker and thinking forward to the long, loud hours after school/before dinner the next day when the Ghost of Mother Future visited me. One day these boys will no longer return to our house. No shoes to put away. No screaming matches to mediate. That inevitable quiet, foretold in this present 3am stillness, filled me with dread. The chaos of motherhood can feel unbearable until one contemplates the alternative. I can barely write this without my throat tightening.

I have never read my boys The Giving Tree. That book offends and grieves me. He comes back to her when he needs something from her. (Should we wonder that the tree is a "she"?) What does the tree get in return? She gets sat on! All that for the privilege of his ass on her back. Typical. This book not only conflicts with my coming-of-age politics, it offends my inchoate sense of environmental justice. Exploitation of Mothers = Exploitation of Mother Earth! High priestesses of Gaia/ Cybele, rise up! This is not the version of motherhood that I want to teach, so I guard the secret truth: I too would give my kids my apples, limbs and trunk even without a guarantee that they would come visit my stump.

So what is Mother's Day really about? To judge from the florist at the end of my street, it's about running out to buy Mom cut flowers on Sunday morning and a greeting card with a message written by an unpublished novelist in a cubicle at Hallmark. These are nice. (But involve maiming more plants.) Jordy and the boys gave me a very pretty necklace.

But my lingering question is, what do Moms really want on this day? Or at least, what do I want? I like holidays that act as reminders of actions we should often take -- remembering the dead, celebrating political freedom, giving thanks, the rebirth of hope, etc. Sadly, we can't even seem to remember for that single day, devolving as these holidays often do into ritual equations such as Independence = grilled burgers and beer, Hope = a new Wii. Rarely do they evoke the kinds of reflection that say, at its best, a good Passover seder demands. The engine of such reflection is imagination, putting oneself in someone else's shoes -- the fearful Israelite, the fighting Colonist, the starving Pilgrim, the Mother.

Yesterday by 11am, we wandered out to the sidewalk where the boys found all the neighborhood kids and their parents gathered with no particular plans for the day. The four mothers in the crowd had all surrendered our roles as Social Coordinators for the day. As a result, Mother's Day on Howard Place looked like a people adrift. (Truth be told, this masculine-inspired aimlessness resulted in delightful serendipitous play time for kids and parents alike.) The mothers struck up a discussion over whether Mother's Day meant we should "relish our roles as mother" by spending the entire day in the company of our children (the fathers thought this sounded good, which we promised to remind them of on Father's Day), or whether it meant we should be relieved of our motherly duties. And if so, what did that mean? Spa treatments? Lunch with our girlfriends?

What I want on Mother's Day is an indication that my family has taken the time to imagine my role and talk amongst themselves about what I give the family as the Mom and come up with some way to express their understanding. The problem with The Giving Tree is not only that the boy/man asks her to give again and again, it's that he takes her for granted. He never once pauses to imagine her as a being that exists for any reason other that serving his needs, or even how simply not to destroy her through his own taking. If Mother's Day hadn't been hijacked by Hallmark, maybe that boy would have learned to think about bringing the tree fertilizer. Or harvesting her apples in a sustainable way. Perhaps making a bench from one of her limbs instead of chopping the whole thing down. Moms, like trees, offer a lot more protective shade when they are left standing.

But like the tree, I felt mute to ask for what I wanted yesterday. By 3pm Jordy could tell I was tired and frustrated. Without a plan for the day, we all spent a lot of time waiting around the house trying to figure out what to do (never a good idea for us). Jordy's efforts to get the older boys out of the house to give me "peace and quiet" were well-intentioned, but most of the time they were out I was caring for the (awake) Baby Tucker -- not a chore, time I relish, but nonetheless, not a deviation from my regular days. Duncan had mentioned making dinner "for me," which reflects the assumption (rightly based in every day experience) that Mommy Makes Dinner, hence even feeding themselves was a gesture of kindness "to me," but Jordy, without whose help Duncan's ambitions wouldn't materialize, hadn't mentioned it, so I was unclear whether I should be getting dinner ready. When Jordy detected my exhaustion (up 5 times the night before)/restlessness/annoyance that no particular imaginative effort had been made about the day, he confronted me. "Tell me what you want," he asked.

The problem in answering his simple question was that the answer lay in what I wanted THEM to do, except the boys are 5 and 3 and hence depend on his leadership, so I really meant HIM. Jordy knew that and did not take it well. (Smacks of passive aggression. Felt yucky saying it too.) I am not his mother, but I wanted him to teach our boys how not to take me for granted, how to love me in ways beyond the function I serve to make their lives better/function. I wanted them to reflect on what I give that can go unnoticed in the flurry of daily life. I would have loved a gesture -- open to interpretation! -- that showed sympathy and understanding of how very much time I spend anticipating and attending to other people's needs. (I make a separate shopping trip to get the specific brands of cheese and cereal they all like!) In other words, I would have liked to have my needs anticipated, which of course, begins with imagining them.

I sound like a whiner. We don't like trees or women who complain about being under-appreciated. My mother gives my grandmother a hard time for insisting on Thank-You notes -- if that doesn't teach you not to demand appreciation, what will? And anyway, isn't the highest spiritual good to give without requiring acknowledgment? Or, more practically, can't I appreciate the daily tokens of acknowledgment my family gives me? My husband is adorable and extremely expressive of his love. He initiates the laundry when his underwear drawer is empty. He unloads the dishwasher without being asked. He reminds the boys to thank me for dinner. Duncan makes me a beaded necklace almost every Friday at school; Reeve runs into my arms at the end of the school day, "MOMMY!" Their desire for Mama-snuggles at bedtime and wake-up are actions speaking louder than words. (And in fairness and thanks to Jordy, he made a lovely spaghetti dinner, did all the dishes, walked the dog, and took out the trash.) Maybe the problem is the concentration of expectations into a single day. Why should we pressure ourselves to "fit it all in"? How contrived!

But again, I hear Rabbi so-and-so giving a midrash on such-and-such parsha about why we are bound to observe ritual days in the calendar: To remind us to direct our attention to things we need to do to keep ourselves morally or spiritually intact, usually involving either making good with people we love or with God. I am not ready to give up on Mother's Day as a meaningful day in the calendar. What will happen when the boys no longer need morning snuggles? Will they remember their old mama?

On my dog walk yesterday morning, I found a bird's nest that had fallen from a tree. I felt the mothers of my youth -- my mom, my step-mom, my aunt Sue-- exclaim, "Oo! Won't the children find that interesting!" as I picked it up and carried it home from Prospect Park. As my boys peered into it, I realized this was another woman's empty nest! Do those baby birds remember how carefully their mom sat on them in this nest? Do they appreciate how hard this bird mom and dad worked to construct this little home? I almost cried.

Duncan and Reeve snatched the nest from my hands and turned it into a crown, then a frisbee. Of course those baby birds don't remember. They are too busy making their own nests, finding worms, and juggling complicated brooding schedules. Maybe this is why Jordy forgot to send his mom a card. And maybe this is the greatest expression of love for one's mother: to undertake the making of your own nest, knowing the babies will fly away without calling (or even Skyping) as often as we'd like.

But next year, I won't wait. I won't even drop hints. Come Monday before Mother's Day, I'll ask flat out: So, guys, what's the plan for Mother's Day? And if they can't come up with anything, I'll help them imagine.